By Rick Bretz
In recognition of the inauguration this week, I have listed what I consider the best presidential portrayals on film and the small screen. My criteria are simple. Did the actor capture the spirit of the President’s personality? And, was I able to watch the presentation without being aware that someone was trying too hard to play that particular president? Most of the performances on this list present a narrow window in a President’s life. The more difficult portrayals involve playing the person over a lifetime. A good example of this is Paul Giamatti’s portrayal of John Adams and Barry Bostwick’s performance in the George Washington miniseries. Below is the actor followed by the President portrayed and then the film or television title.
1. Kenneth Branagh-Franklin Delano Roosevelt-Warm Springs
I was skeptical before making time to see this show that the actor could pull it off. I was wrong. Kenneth Branagh captured the force of Roosevelt’s personality and his physical and emotional fight with the crippling polio disease. He also does a great job of relating to the people who have the same disease while rehabilitating at Warm Springs. His supporting cast is terrific and he shows us why Roosevelt related to so many people.
2. Daniel Day Lewis-Abraham-Lincoln-Lincoln
Enough has been written about Lewis’ choice concerning how Lincoln sounds when he speaks compared to other portrayals. If you watch Henry Fonda’s “Young Mr. Lincoln”, the voice pitch comes close to what Lewis used in Lincoln. What cannot be disputed is that he does capture Lincoln’s modest confidence and his sharp political mind.
3. Paul Giamatti-John Adams-Johns Adams
Paul Giamatti captures Adams from all directions. He is spot on in his portrayal in many aspects. His love for his wife Abigail, his mercurial temper, his difficult personality, his love for his family, his ego, and most of all, his sense of duty, fairness, and love for his country. Giamatti’s choices show the president from all sides while weaving his multi-layered personality into the presentation of Adams. He also plays him as he ages from a young man to his death which is difficult to accomplish.
4. Frank Langella-Richard M. Nixon-Frost/Nixon
Langella’s acting puts a human face on Richard Nixon in this Ron Howard directed film. He sparred with David Frost through a majority of the movie and showed Nixon’s toughness, intellect, political savvy and his personality weaknesses. This performance is remarkable because it keeps the audience interested despite knowing the outcome. It explains history without getting into the minute details so the audience’s eyes don’t glaze over like sitting in 9th grade history class memorizing dates.
5. Jeff Daniels-George Washington-The Crossing
Jeff Daniels does a terrific job showing people what it must have been like serving under George Washington. Daniels gives us a performance that shows Washington cool under fire, a master at finding quality people to serve under him and how to manage them, and how to get soldiers to fight for him in the most extreme circumstances. Daniels as Washington shows the General as calm leader looking to find answers instead of assessing blame.
6. Anthony Hopkins-John Quincy Adams-Amistad
My favorite scene in this movie is when Adams is supposedly sleeping during a congressional session. Then the speaker asks him to comment on the previous discussion. Adams speaks up immediately repeating the last exchange and giving his own caustic opinion about the matter and the current session itself. Hopkins is a master at losing himself in roles and this is one. His other Presidential portrayal of Richard Nixon is good as well but this one is fascinating especially with the final summation in court at the end.
Randy Quaid shows Lyndon Johnson with his loud voice, over-the–top personality and his energy to accomplish his own goals and fix what needs to be fixed. This is another performance that shows the actor aging through several years from a young man to his days in congress. Quaid gives an outstanding performance showing how Johnson dealt with people and how Johnson used his force of personality to get his legislation passed when he was a leader in congress.
8. Henry Fonda-Abraham Lincoln-Young Mr. Lincoln
This movie was released in 1939 and it shows a young Henry Fonda at his best. Fonda gives us the Lincoln personality in the salad days of his lawyer career. He takes on a case early in the movie that everyone believes is a lost cause. Throughout the movie, Fonda shows the audience the Lincoln wit and his art for storytelling. He shows us why Lincoln became President while using his political savvy and intelligence. Fonda’s acting also shows us an underlying sadness to his personality and an innate understanding he might be destined for great things.
Those are my favorites. Do you agree? Leave a comment?
More great characterizations:
David Morse-George Washington-John Adams; Edward Herrmann-Franklin Delano Roosevelt-Eleanor and Franklin; Barry Bostwick-George Washington- George Washington (The Mini-Series); Bill Murray-Franklin Delano Roosevelt-Hyde Park on the Hudson; Gary Sinise-Harry S. Truman-Truman; James Whitmore-Harry S. Truman-Give ‘Em Hell Harry; Raymond Massey-Abraham Lincoln-Abe Lincoln in Illinois; Brian Keith-Teddy Roosevelt-The Wind and the Lion